Well we're trying to plan our honeymoon for March at the moment, and we've narrowed it down to 7 locations. We're trying to do either an all-inclusive for under $2000 each incl airfare, or a build your own for $1500 each which will leave money for food.
We want to snorkel, sit on the beach, swim, walk around little shops, and hopefully have some easy hikes/walking trails but nothing too crazy (if we want to go crazy we can do that in Alberta).
I'd love to hear what people think of any of these places, specific resorts, etc.! Last time I went south was in '94 and I was 13... Went to Acapulco and had fun, but again, I was 13.
Edit: I should mention the wifey (to be) doesn't want to do Mexico, Cuba or the Dominican. And like casual says, gotta keep the wifey happy!