The Weakerthans of course.
The Weakerthans - The Reasons
Excellent band, only one cd and they broke up, but I've been listening to it since 2005 or so.... so yeah lol
Dude. They have more than one album. iTunes that shit. I've got two by them. I think they put out 3. John K Sampson (lead singer) still tours and sings some of their songs. Amazing band, none the less.
Also: without your old avatar I didn't even realize who was posting.
This is, by far, my favorite song by them. The album is "Left and Leaving" (2000) and I freaking love it. I hope this makes your day. The Weakerthans are amazing.
Also, by Thrice I would go with "See you in the shallows."