Thanks for the feedback. Every hour that goes by it hurts a little less. I will keep watching Craigslist and eBay.
check your homeowners insurance. There may be a personal articles policy with a low limit, but you may have a deductible so it may be a wash.
Personal articles policy from State Farm. It's $13 per $1,000 in coverage, per year. No deductible, and it does not count against you as a homeowners claim.
I don't cover my snowboards, I cover my photography equipment ($8,000). In the future, you can cover your boards all for $13 a year or so, depending on receipt and value.