Yup, the blackhawks and phantoms would be good for you, your board and how you plan to ride. For you it will be personal preference between the 2. Both are at the higher end of the Raiden lineup, so I wouldn't expect any major quality issues and the ratchets/ladders are smooth. Worst case, if you don't like the quality when you get them return/exchange them.
Without knowing what models people are bitching about it's hard to say if it's a quality issue, or a pricepoint issue. Every binding has little things people can and will nitpik, but overall the complaints on a quality binding are not something to concerning. There's always exceptions to this, that's why specifics are needed.