Thanks a lot for the detailed reply Arrrmaty! This actually really helped. I always though if the toes are just barely touching then it's loose. A lot of people say to have all of the toes touching the tip because of the pack out that will happen. The boots I have now have that barely skimming feeling but are more comfortable for me then having my toes all touching the tip (my toes would turn a bit red if that was to happen). When i kick with my boots on, they don't slide at all. Looks like I'll be keeping these boots!
Well awesome, I'm glad I was able to help. And you got to keep the boots that you ultimately wanted too, so win win. It sounds like you have a good fit, and the correct fit. Happy riding