Quick update for anyone who cares
Since it is now later in the season, the boot selection in my size at stores was very limited. I first tried on some Burtons and Vans, but they were too narrow. There were no DC or Salomon boots available to try.
In the end, I was debating between the 32 STW BOA and the Lashed. Although I loved the idiot proof ease of the BOA, the single BOA did not fit right (good fit on the foot, but too loose around the ankle/calf). Unfortunately, there were no double BOA boots to try on. I eventually settled on the 32 Lashed (with laces) for $150.
I'm just glad that I never have to wear uncomfortable rentals again! Thanks to everyone for their help.