I have the Mayhem short fat and had the 2017 Storm Chaser. The latter was super loose because of the spoon nose/tail and full rocker, which also made it one of the most fun boards I've ever ridden. That said, the Mayhem is also super fun, with more control on landings and outside of deep pow. Then again you're looking at the older Storm Chaser, which doesn't have the spoon but still had full rocker, so it will still be fairly loose. You should really checkout the Rossi Sushi 145, K2 Cool Bean 144, and Lib Coho 146 also.
18 Snoplanks Asym Fish . 16 NS Swift - 14 TJ Brand Retro Fish
17 Burton Malavita Wing . 16 Burton Genesis X
16 Flow Talon