Thanks for the response. I did know that about the boots and I chose the boots I did because they actually hug my foot better than any of the other boots that I've tried. I have a pretty narrow foot and I seem to have a problem with my heel sliding up in most other boots. These Nike's literally do fit like a glove. I'm hoping they'll pack out some and be perfect. They're not at the point where my foot is falling asleep, they're just really snug like I said before. My toes don't curl in them and when I'm in a crouched position, they don't touch the end of the insert, but they do feel snug at all times.
I figured if they don't become more comfortable, I can always try selling them on ebay for around what I paid (I paid $85) and get some 10.5's and try them instead.