Rode both last year, though the PP was a bit undersized. Overall, Evo had more snap off the lips and just gave better positive lock into presses and boards. It definitely beat the PP on jumps because the camber profile felt better coming off the lip and sticking off-center landings, though the latter was pretty good on the PP. Pickle beat the Evo buttering, but only slightly and mostly due to the softer flex from the shorter size. I'd give the nod to the Evo, though the Pickle isn't bad but given how close the price is, I'd go with the Evo since it does everything a little bit better.
Check out the Arbor Westmark, too.