Ill give ya 2cents.
I am having my best luck ever with boots going to 32's this year. FWIW: my feet are flat and wide.
The Moto is the best selling boot for the past 10 years or something like that. There could be many reasons for this, among which I would imagine is them not sucking. My riding buddy has been wearing a pair of Moto's that he bought used for over 3 seasons. They aren't very stiff but you can buy stiff boots when you are good enough to know you need them.
If comfort is not an issue, buy either the cheapest one, or the most expensive depending on if you want to save or invest (in whatever frills the more expensive option offers).
Support Local Business
"Shop Smart. Shop S-Mart!" - Ash