check out azzpadz. Ive used the red total impact and the protec one. I think the red made me hurt myself even more. Wasnt comfy and didnt provide any protection. azzpadz are comfy and its low profile. Def much better than the red impact shorts if your looking for butt protection. If you want protection on the thighs and hips look at something else. But for pure tailbone and butt protection azzpadz is the way to go.