I'll throw another recommendation out there for Outdoor Research stuff. You'll stay dry and warm all day and they have a Lifetime Warranty...pop a seem or anything and they will replace them free. Outdoor Research -- Handwear - OR Gear
my gf got me the northface montana mitts and im surprised how nice they are. waterproof, and keeps the snow out. it was between 45-50 yesterday so my hands got a little sweaty at points but the inside doesn't seem to retain moisture.