While I am new to this forum, I am certainly not new to private online buying, selling, and trading. With over 10 years of expertise in using other forums, craigslist, and ebay, I know what it takes to make all parties feel comfortable in the transaction. That is why posted feedback is so important.
Despite how small this forum is, the current method for leaving feedback is a bit disorganized.
PBNation is the biggest sports-related forum on the internet. Private buying, selling, and trading is so popular there, that the website makes huge profits selling gold ups for classified threads. The current system that they have is a but overkill for this site, but the old system would work really well.
Simply put, instead of one thread for B/S/T feedback, there is a subforum to the B/S/T forum specific to leaving feedback. Users make their own "Feedback thread," where other users can post to leave that specific person detailed feedback.
An example is of this system is here:
Feedback for Deimus85 - PbNation
Let me know what you guys think of this suggestion.