I've got the Dakine low roller and am pretty happy with it so far. It fits boards that are bigger than it says, and is padded pretty well. Seems to be high quality and I expect it to last me a long time. I can get two boards w/ bindings on one, helmet, boots, clothing etc in it without much issue.
There are a couple things I don't like about it though. My boots don't fit in the pockets on the ends that are made for this purpose, but it's not like that reduces the amount of useable space in the bag. Also the shoulder strap attaches on opposite sides of the main zipper, so when you need to completely open the bag up it helps to disconnect the strap on one end.
Not exactly sure how the high roller would compare on features, but it's probably as good a bag as any in the price range.