Depends on who's watching. burritosandsnow apparently doesn't like Travis Rice because he tends to huck, lots of people (Most maybe) think Shaun White is better because while he can't go as big as Rice, he looks a lot cleaner doing it. I'm a lot more impressed with Rice because, well, dude's doing like 3600's into space, I don't care if his arms are waving. On the other hand, Gretchen Bleiler tends to go biggest of all the women, but I find her one of the least impressive because she's flaily as all shit.
So what I guess I'm saying is, style usually wins, but if you're doing something absolutely ridiculous, it's ok if it's not clean. Because after all, thousands of people can do stylish 3s, only a handful can throw 12s, sketched out or not.