Snowboarding Forum - Snowboard Enthusiast Forums banner

1 - 12 of 12 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
5 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Narrowed it down to these two boards, which one fits me better?

I mostly ride in the North East but I do go out West ever few years.
Blue Mountain PA, Mountain Creek NJ, Hunter NY, Stowe VT are the mountains I ride the most.

I'll ride the whole mountain but at the smaller resorts I stay in the park the whole day hitting only jumps. I'm not into rails or boxes much anymore.
Only about 15% of my riding is switch, mostly when I'm messing around on smaller jumps or cruising a little slower waiting for my wife to catch up.

Currently on a 2010 Skate Banana 156w.
(I probably should have bought a reg 156 but it was all the shop had at the time.) It's a really fun board but I think it's more for goofing around on then owning the mountain. Problem with the board is in my opinion it has no pop and can't hold a turn when going fast, it feels like I'm just power sliding around the mountain. The extruded base gets painfully slow when the snow warms up.


I could go back to my old Rome Anthem deck which rode pretty good but I've grown to like the catch free riding of a reverse camber board. SO I was thinking about going to a hybrid camber board.

Any feedback is well appreciated. :thumbsup:

Thanks,
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,055 Posts
I don't know much about the Banana Magic, but the 2013 BSOD I tried out late last season was pretty fun.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
898 Posts
I'm thinking about finding a leftover Banana Magic myself....

though I don't go to Creek... as I loathe that place (and can see some of South peak trails from my house)....
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5 Posts
Discussion Starter #4 (Edited)
I don't know much about the Banana Magic, but the 2013 BSOD I tried out late last season was pretty fun.
Hey man, Yeah thanks, I read your review last night. I was a little worried about what you and a few others said about it stability in chop and tracks, other then that it sounded pretty good.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5 Posts
Discussion Starter #5
I'm thinking about finding a leftover Banana Magic myself....

though I don't go to Creek... as I loathe that place (and can see some of South peak trails from my house)....
Yeah I can find any local shops that have it in stock. Ill like to buy local and also see it in person first.

Yeah creek does suck 90% of the time but the tickets are cheap if you get a triple play card.
They setup a decent park but they are the absolute worst at taking care of the setups and landings.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
1,966 Posts
Narrowed it down to these two boards, which one fits me better?

I mostly ride in the North East but I do go out West ever few years.
Blue Mountain PA, Mountain Creek NJ, Hunter NY, Stowe VT are the mountains I ride the most.

I'll ride the whole mountain but at the smaller resorts I stay in the park the whole day hitting only jumps. I'm not into rails or boxes much anymore.
Only about 15% of my riding is switch, mostly when I'm messing around on smaller jumps or cruising a little slower waiting for my wife to catch up.

Currently on a 2010 Skate Banana 156w.
(I probably should have bought a reg 156 but it was all the shop had at the time.) It's a really fun board but I think it's more for goofing around on then owning the mountain. Problem with the board is in my opinion it has no pop and can't hold a turn when going fast, it feels like I'm just power sliding around the mountain. The extruded base gets painfully slow when the snow warms up.


I could go back to my old Rome Anthem deck which rode pretty good but I've grown to like the catch free riding of a reverse camber board. SO I was thinking about going to a hybrid camber board.

Any feedback is well appreciated. :thumbsup:

Thanks,
For the riding you describe, the BSOD hands down. Magic is essentially a powder twin - not what you are looking for at all.

It also sounds like you need to put in a few more hours/days on the Skate Banana, because with proper technique it easily holds a turn at almost any speed. However, being a wide might have something to do with your problem - you will need to use really good technique.

Oh, and unless it is this year's model, the Skate Banana has a sintered base (and even this year's model has a base that is plenty fast).
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5 Posts
Discussion Starter #7
For the riding you describe, the BSOD hands down. Magic is essentially a powder twin - not what you are looking for at all.

It also sounds like you need to put in a few more hours/days on the Skate Banana, because with proper technique it easily holds a turn at almost any speed. However, being a wide might have something to do with your problem - you will need to use really good technique.

Oh, and unless it is this year's model, the Skate Banana has a sintered base (and even this year's model has a base that is plenty fast).
Thanks for the recommendation! You're right about the 2010 SB being a sintered base, I looked at the sticker last night. Man I don't know what is up with it though it's so slow, and in spring conditions forget it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3 Posts
Not sure I agree with the "powder twin" comment on the banana magic. It carves very well and pops from edge to edge unlike anything else I've ridden. I've ridden custom, custom X's, and I currently have a Rome Anthem as well.

There's a review out there on youtube with it compared to the skate and attack banana's, got lots of good info, give that a view.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5 Posts
Discussion Starter #9
Not sure I agree with the "powder twin" comment on the banana magic. It carves very well and pops from edge to edge unlike anything else I've ridden. I've ridden custom, custom X's, and I currently have a Rome Anthem as well.

There's a review out there on youtube with it compared to the skate and attack banana's, got lots of good info, give that a view.
Yeah I watched that video, it made me a little confused, two of the guys said out of the three boards the Skate Banana had the most pop. ??? :dizzy:
My '10 SB has no pop, maybe they changed since then?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
730 Posts
Both are going to perform quite similarly but with a very different feel...both are marketed as an aggressive all mountain. The different feel will be the difference btw camber in the middle, or rocker in the middle...but it looks like you have done your research!

A "cons only" list usually sways me with these things, so here you go!

LTBM: biobeans topsheet(lots of complaints on here about it!), true twin (no set back on deep days).
BSOD: directional sidecut....thats it?

Personally whatever poor traits you can live with easiest, get that one. Although I have never heard anyone complain about the BSOD....and I have about the BM.

While they are both quite similar (magne, sintered, 6-7 flex, basalt, etc) I would go with the BSOD...set back or twin options, camber underfoot to really get alot of pop out of the board.

Good luck! put up a review either way!!
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
1,966 Posts
LTBM: biobeans topsheet(lots of complaints on here about it!), true twin (no set back on deep days).
Seriously, the topsheet is a big problem? And a couple of guys posting in the last day or two bout messing up theirs counts "lots of complaints"!?
True twin is also not a problem for deep days - even without setback the BM floats much better than the BSOD because it has much more rocker in the camber profile.

While they are both quite similar (magne, sintered, 6-7 flex, basalt, etc)
They are not very similar at all - quite different boards, in fact. They are just similar in a couple of details.

I would go with the BSOD
At least we agree on that...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
730 Posts
They are not very similar at all - quite different boards, in fact. They are just similar in a couple of details.
I only meant in the form of technology that is incorporated into them hence the list....of course they are different boards! the feel of RCR vs CRC is such a HUGE difference when you ride them one right after another. Do you have a BSOD? Have you posted a review of it...I ALMOST bought it last year but settled with the YES Big City (pow performance was the deal breaker)....and now that I have a pow specific board, I regret it greatly....
 
1 - 12 of 12 Posts
Top