Mondo point boot sizing is done in increments of 5 mm. Hence you need 255, which is intended for sizes of 251 - 255. This should work nicely for both your feet. How this translates into US size is something you should look up at the manufacturer, and looking at Sizing, you can see that size 7.5 US is 255 mondo. Meaning up to (including) 255 mm (starting from 251).
A size 7.5 US would be the correct fit for you.
A size 7.5 US would be the correct fit for you.