Snowboarding Forum - Snowboard Enthusiast Forums banner
Status
Not open for further replies.
61 - 80 of 354 Posts
I am seeing more snowboarders with his "evolve" sticker on their boards lately. There are obviously much bigger problems in the world than this, especially in the last week or so, but you won't find me with that sticker.
(evolution is "only a theory" after all)
I saw the sticker first and actually liked it, but goddamn that guy's content sucks.
 
I hate that I had to sign into this website because one of your or maybe it wasn't sent me this crap.

First and foremost, don't ever besmirch the legacy that is Fred Rodgers. EVER! That guy deserves Sainthood status. Buckhouse will NEVER BE ON HIS LEVEL. All of us posting here could learn a thing or two from Mr. Rodgers and how to be good humans and I say this completely hypocritical because I hate everyone.

Now lets dive into the 10,000 word essay I'm about to write because unlike Buckhouse I didn't learn how to read in the 5th grade and can actually articulate a thought beyond the wet farts he expels from his suck hole.

To anyone that says he "rides better than me so that makes him pro", "his videos are slick and polished", or " I wish I could be like him". You need to up your standards because they're fucking dog shit!

As someone that's done team development and brand building he isn't even good enough to be considered D team. The regional guys that ride Copper are better than him on their worst day. Early offs, zeaches, only hits the small shit and yes the jumps he hits are the small line, his 630 to 90 reverts and claiming 720's, and the fact he CAN'T EVEN FUCKING HOLD AN EDGE! Don't even get me started on his switch riding. Dudes skill level is so mediocre maybe some of you praising his riding should spend some time upping your game because it's soggy. I say this as someone that's watched him ride in person multiple times a season.

Polished and quality? He uses a whack follow cam angle with a wide angle lens. There's nothing cinematic about it, he's doing the basic minimum to cut the start/end of a clip and try to sync it to music, music he just found for free on Soundcloud and isn't given the artist any credit. You want polished and stylized, go watch an old ISENSEVEN edit and you'll see they were surpassing anything he did 15 years ago. His angles are whack and he's beholden to the Hypersmooth 2.0 on his GoPro. If you gave him a real camera he would look like a monkey fucking a football as he fumbled it. Once again repeat after me "UP YOUR STANDARDS!"

Anyone that wishes they could be like him I feel bad for. I'm in a unique position that 1. I live locally to him and see how he treats people here. 2. I also get a lot of DM's on the gram with conversations people have had with him. Who he projects himself as vs who he is are two different things and a lot of people have a para-social relationship with him that puts the blinders on them. Dude would sell anyone out for a dollar and he has. I've seen him belittle a 15 year old kid for being "poor" because the kid called out his sloppy spins and claims of being pro. You're a 32 year old male talking down to a kid about how much money you make, how his parents pay for his phone still, and how you're getting paid to snowboard and make mediocre content. As much as I love talking shit to 15 year olds, it's mostly because I understand the cultural aspect of snowboarding and how to make them rethink their I know everything attitude and hope that it enlightens them. The generation above me did it to me and so I shall continue it.

Is he a pro snowboarder? NO! Unequivocally he's not even in the realm of a real pro snowboarder. What he is, is a professional vlogger who uses YouTube as his medium coupled with snowboarding. By the peoples standards that he is a "pro" I too am a pro then. I get paid to ride snowboards, it's a great job, and I'm making a good living at it. But I am not a pro snowboarder and neither is he. Which going into the whole aspect of him claiming he's pro, he started giving himself that title when his fan base kept asking if he was. They asked this because their standards are too fucking low. In that time he tried to change the narrative at one point to say that his "haters" gave him that title and put it back on them. What he realized was that using "pro" in the title of videos became clickbait and it upped where his videos are presented in the YouTube Algorithm. It's much like how I use the tag "expert advice" in all my reviews and videos. It pushes them higher internally in YouTube. Is he paying his bills from vlogging about snowboarding? Yeah. But I'm also paying my bills by doing video reviews about snowboards. If you put him on the pro level, you have to put people like me and idiot Kevin from SnowboardProCamp there as well. News flash, we all suck as riders and shouldn't be on the pro level. Casey on the other hand is an anomaly in the YouTube sphere as he rides at a professional level, films at a mostly professional level, and in a true sense of the word is a real professional. I'm stoked to see him get a legit promodel and hope that it helps elevate his personal brand to the people that snowboard.

Now lets talk about his bullshit at Keystone. First and foremost he never once put up the "unedited" interaction he had. It has jump cuts all over it and he puts himself in there to interject his .02 on everything. I actually got popped about 12 years ago in that same spot and had my pass pulled on a midweek day during the WWSRA demo for doing a Euro carve right around that corner. This was the first time I got banned for life from Vail Resorts. He was riding on a Saturday on School Marm doing jackass shit. I actually talked with one of the Mountain Safety that made the call to stop him, what you guys saw and what caused it and the interaction is not what happened. If he had played it cool they would have given him a verbal warning over the written one that goes into your pass holder file. He didn't have to attend a safety class, but if he did anything else that season that riled them up he would. What happened was his wife (she actually runs the show) convinced him to push it to the local media and make the vlogs about it (she's an even worse human than him). They made it a big deal, when it wasn't. Anyone that's ridden Keystone knows that Schoolmarm is a 2 mile long beginner run that is a family friendly zone. On weekends you don't do jackass shit on it. But he wanted to play the victim, and that's what he did. That video made him about 3k in revenue, gained him I think something like 39k new subscribers and boosted his ego. From there he changed to the clickbait format.

He is essentially the king of the kooks. His logo is stolen from a T-Shirt shop in Steamboat, he tried to trademark it. It's literally been on t-shirts since the mid 90's. Have you ever asked yourself why most self respecting brand will not work with him? It took him over 5 years to get that Christy's sponsorship and that only happened because they are in the midst of an organization change as the company sold. The reason he's on Clew is because he begged the local Union guys for free stuff because it would up their "amazon sales as he's a highly influential vlogger". My friend that runs the account he reached out to blocked him and laughed. Dudes so delusional he thinks that Amazon sales help the local reps sales. They don't. He should have done something to promote the local shops, but he has never once set foot in a core shop, because it's beneath him.

Three days ago a colleague of mine that runs the marketing department for a little resort sent me screen shots from their front office guy who had an interaction with Buckhouse. Basically he walked in dropped his business card, demanded multiple free lift tickets, and was offended when the guy at the counter didn't know who he was. This is a little mom and pop resort that the tickets are very affordable at. For someone that likes to brag about how much money they're making he sure seems to refuse to pay it into the industry that sustains him. Kind of a jackass move and shows how much of a peasant he truly is. Kevin from ProCamp is doing the same shit and actually tried to tell a resort in Idaho they needed to pay him to come to their resort and film a vlog. Entitlement is a hell of a drug.

Earlier this week I ran into Tommie B and had a nice long chat with him about Youtube, Snowboarding, Buckhouse, and the state of the culture and industry. Actually walked away with more respect for Tommie and a better understanding of where he's coming from. But I also got the run down of why he and Buckhouse aren't working together. It boils down to ego and how Buckhouse will sell out over and over for the first person to wave 20 bucks in front of his face. It's why he jumped from Outdoor Master to Khuno to Clew to whomever will dangle cheap cash in his face. Dude doesn't care about snowboarding at all he cares about exploiting it. But at the same time he wants the respect of people in snowboarding. It's rather comedic.

To add another reason why he sucks to this I'll talk about his interactions with my friend AJ who is a San Juan Guide. AJ saw in reels or some shit that he was talking about Backcountry and splitboards. For frame of reference AJ is a devoted guide, been buried, extricated bodies, and done rescues. I'd put my life in his hands without any hesitation because he's just that educated and devoted. But basically he reached out to Buckhouse to say "hey I see you're in CO and trying to do some BC stuff, you're giving out some bad advice, but if you wanted to learn the proper way to do things and make yourself a stronger rider and educated your base I'd be willing to help." His response was something along the lines of "yeah I don't know what I'm talking about but it doesn't matter because neither does my fanbase" That's some serious ego shit right there that needs to be put in check. This is along the lines of idiot Kevin filming and riding in Whistler in a avy zone as they were blasting (this is why Kevin doesn't have an epic pass this year and isn't in Whistler).

I'm going to have to continue this...
 
*Continued...

So if you want to talk about the proliferation of his growth and what not lets dive into the shitty side of YouTube.

Everyone thinks it's as simple as film, upload, and promote and you're there. But behind all that is the grand YouTube algorithm that we are all beholden to. Buckhouse came onto YouTube at what is the start of the end of the Vlog lifestyle crap that has dominated it. We're actually in a shift from that to what will be next i.e. Mr. Beast style content for those that know. At that time YT was favoring content going to a longer format as they can add a mid roll video ad to it. This favors Google Ads as well as the content producer as it's keeping people on the app, site, or wherever its embedded. Most people think the real metric for success is subscribers and views, but a view is counted after 30 seconds of watching and most subscribers aren't addicts that watch everything, they're casual viewers. The real metric is view time and audience retention. If you do a 5 minute video you want them to watch over 3 minutes of it and if they stick around through the whole thing and watch what's recommended next then you get preferential treatment. If you make a 20 minute video and keep peoples attention for 50% of that it means it hits the mid roll ad and that preferential treatment comes back into play. So by gaming the system with a 20 minute video full of a shit load of filler and merchandise hawking he's hitting this goal. Now one other metric to look at is subscriber count to views in the first 24 hours. YouTube will naturally promote it to 1/3rd of your audience, if it hits the above listed goals you might be able to hit 50% of your audience and if it exceeds that you'll his 2/3rds of it which is insane. After that the algorithm changes again and shit gets weird. I won't bore you guys with the theories on how this works. But just understand if you're in a niche, using clickbait titles/thumbnails, and hit their metrics of time/audience retention you get boosted.

The daily content grind exists because of this format. If you don't do a daily video, you get buried in the algorithm. So he's beholden to clickbait bullshit and mediocre daily content to stay relevant. Andy Warhol was right about our 15 minutes of fame. The problem is we now have to prolong it to stay relevant. The sad thing is he doesn't realize this nor does he realize the peaks and valleys of how content is consumed. He's put all his eggs in one basket and when it doesn't work out he's FUBAR!

I guess I should also add the live streaming segment into this. YouTube is failing to Twitch here so they're trying to figure out what does and doesn't work. But this is mostly personality based. I've suffered through having to watch some of his and Kevins live streams to see how much audience they attract. They roughly get about .1% of their audience when they do it. Why? Near as I can tell the sycophant fanboys are there and the rest of their audiences find them boring as they don't give actual value, and why would they? This is them unedited in raw form, they aren't entertaining people. This also goes to why you will more than likely never see a Bombhole with Buckhouse, he can't control the narrative and it would show how boring he is.

In short for those that are still with me here. He makes kook content for kooks. He's not a snowboarder, but a person that snowboards and vlogs. Nothing wrong with that, but the fact that he takes from snowboarding with 0 giving back (don't use the argument of him making content is giving back, that's his job if he wants a paycheck he has to make content), at the end of the day he sucks as a human. If you don't like his content don't watch it, report the shit that is dangerous because there's plenty (I'm honestly waiting for him or Kevin to get someone killed with their kookery), and inform people not to watch him.

And for those of you that will say "you're just jealous". I took 10 weeks off last year, I snowboard 150 days a year, and get paid to ride a piece of wood and plastic down the hill. I think I'm doing just fine. What I don't like is fighting all the misinformation and bad advice he and Kevin give people. If they didn't do that, more power to them for figuring out how to snowboard more and make a living at it. Remember only you can prevent kookery in snowboarding.

Thank you for coming to my TED Talk.
 
I hate that I had to sign into this website because one of your or maybe it wasn't sent me this crap.

First and foremost, don't ever besmirch the legacy that is Fred Rodgers. EVER! That guy deserves Sainthood status. Buckhouse will NEVER BE ON HIS LEVEL. All of us posting here could learn a thing or two from Mr. Rodgers and how to be good humans and I say this completely hypocritical because I hate everyone.

Now lets dive into the 10,000 word essay I'm about to write because unlike Buckhouse I didn't learn how to read in the 5th grade and can actually articulate a thought beyond the wet farts he expels from his suck hole.

To anyone that says he "rides better than me so that makes him pro", "his videos are slick and polished", or " I wish I could be like him". You need to up your standards because they're fucking dog shit!

As someone that's done team development and brand building he isn't even good enough to be considered D team. The regional guys that ride Copper are better than him on their worst day. Early offs, zeaches, only hits the small shit and yes the jumps he hits are the small line, his 630 to 90 reverts and claiming 720's, and the fact he CAN'T EVEN FUCKING HOLD AN EDGE! Don't even get me started on his switch riding. Dudes skill level is so mediocre maybe some of you praising his riding should spend some time upping your game because it's soggy. I say this as someone that's watched him ride in person multiple times a season.

Polished and quality? He uses a whack follow cam angle with a wide angle lens. There's nothing cinematic about it, he's doing the basic minimum to cut the start/end of a clip and try to sync it to music, music he just found for free on Soundcloud and isn't given the artist any credit. You want polished and stylized, go watch an old ISENSEVEN edit and you'll see they were surpassing anything he did 15 years ago. His angles are whack and he's beholden to the Hypersmooth 2.0 on his GoPro. If you gave him a real camera he would look like a monkey fucking a football as he fumbled it. Once again repeat after me "UP YOUR STANDARDS!"

Anyone that wishes they could be like him I feel bad for. I'm in a unique position that 1. I live locally to him and see how he treats people here. 2. I also get a lot of DM's on the gram with conversations people have had with him. Who he projects himself as vs who he is are two different things and a lot of people have a para-social relationship with him that puts the blinders on them. Dude would sell anyone out for a dollar and he has. I've seen him belittle a 15 year old kid for being "poor" because the kid called out his sloppy spins and claims of being pro. You're a 32 year old male talking down to a kid about how much money you make, how his parents pay for his phone still, and how you're getting paid to snowboard and make mediocre content. As much as I love talking shit to 15 year olds, it's mostly because I understand the cultural aspect of snowboarding and how to make them rethink their I know everything attitude and hope that it enlightens them. The generation above me did it to me and so I shall continue it.

Is he a pro snowboarder? NO! Unequivocally he's not even in the realm of a real pro snowboarder. What he is, is a professional vlogger who uses YouTube as his medium coupled with snowboarding. By the peoples standards that he is a "pro" I too am a pro then. I get paid to ride snowboards, it's a great job, and I'm making a good living at it. But I am not a pro snowboarder and neither is he. Which going into the whole aspect of him claiming he's pro, he started giving himself that title when his fan base kept asking if he was. They asked this because their standards are too fucking low. In that time he tried to change the narrative at one point to say that his "haters" gave him that title and put it back on them. What he realized was that using "pro" in the title of videos became clickbait and it upped where his videos are presented in the YouTube Algorithm. It's much like how I use the tag "expert advice" in all my reviews and videos. It pushes them higher internally in YouTube. Is he paying his bills from vlogging about snowboarding? Yeah. But I'm also paying my bills by doing video reviews about snowboards. If you put him on the pro level, you have to put people like me and idiot Kevin from SnowboardProCamp there as well. News flash, we all suck as riders and shouldn't be on the pro level. Casey on the other hand is an anomaly in the YouTube sphere as he rides at a professional level, films at a mostly professional level, and in a true sense of the word is a real professional. I'm stoked to see him get a legit promodel and hope that it helps elevate his personal brand to the people that snowboard.

Now lets talk about his bullshit at Keystone. First and foremost he never once put up the "unedited" interaction he had. It has jump cuts all over it and he puts himself in there to interject his .02 on everything. I actually got popped about 12 years ago in that same spot and had my pass pulled on a midweek day during the WWSRA demo for doing a Euro carve right around that corner. This was the first time I got banned for life from Vail Resorts. He was riding on a Saturday on School Marm doing jackass shit. I actually talked with one of the Mountain Safety that made the call to stop him, what you guys saw and what caused it and the interaction is not what happened. If he had played it cool they would have given him a verbal warning over the written one that goes into your pass holder file. He didn't have to attend a safety class, but if he did anything else that season that riled them up he would. What happened was his wife (she actually runs the show) convinced him to push it to the local media and make the vlogs about it (she's an even worse human than him). They made it a big deal, when it wasn't. Anyone that's ridden Keystone knows that Schoolmarm is a 2 mile long beginner run that is a family friendly zone. On weekends you don't do jackass shit on it. But he wanted to play the victim, and that's what he did. That video made him about 3k in revenue, gained him I think something like 39k new subscribers and boosted his ego. From there he changed to the clickbait format.

He is essentially the king of the kooks. His logo is stolen from a T-Shirt shop in Steamboat, he tried to trademark it. It's literally been on t-shirts since the mid 90's. Have you ever asked yourself why most self respecting brand will not work with him? It took him over 5 years to get that Christy's sponsorship and that only happened because they are in the midst of an organization change as the company sold. The reason he's on Clew is because he begged the local Union guys for free stuff because it would up their "amazon sales as he's a highly influential vlogger". My friend that runs the account he reached out to blocked him and laughed. Dudes so delusional he thinks that Amazon sales help the local reps sales. They don't. He should have done something to promote the local shops, but he has never once set foot in a core shop, because it's beneath him.

Three days ago a colleague of mine that runs the marketing department for a little resort sent me screen shots from their front office guy who had an interaction with Buckhouse. Basically he walked in dropped his business card, demanded multiple free lift tickets, and was offended when the guy at the counter didn't know who he was. This is a little mom and pop resort that the tickets are very affordable at. For someone that likes to brag about how much money they're making he sure seems to refuse to pay it into the industry that sustains him. Kind of a jackass move and shows how much of a peasant he truly is. Kevin from ProCamp is doing the same shit and actually tried to tell a resort in Idaho they needed to pay him to come to their resort and film a vlog. Entitlement is a hell of a drug.

Earlier this week I ran into Tommie B and had a nice long chat with him about Youtube, Snowboarding, Buckhouse, and the state of the culture and industry. Actually walked away with more respect for Tommie and a better understanding of where he's coming from. But I also got the run down of why he and Buckhouse aren't working together. It boils down to ego and how Buckhouse will sell out over and over for the first person to wave 20 bucks in front of his face. It's why he jumped from Outdoor Master to Khuno to Clew to whomever will dangle cheap cash in his face. Dude doesn't care about snowboarding at all he cares about exploiting it. But at the same time he wants the respect of people in snowboarding. It's rather comedic.

To add another reason why he sucks to this I'll talk about his interactions with my friend AJ who is a San Juan Guide. AJ saw in reels or some shit that he was talking about Backcountry and splitboards. For frame of reference AJ is a devoted guide, been buried, extricated bodies, and done rescues. I'd put my life in his hands without any hesitation because he's just that educated and devoted. But basically he reached out to Buckhouse to say "hey I see you're in CO and trying to do some BC stuff, you're giving out some bad advice, but if you wanted to learn the proper way to do things and make yourself a stronger rider and educated your base I'd be willing to help." His response was something along the lines of "yeah I don't know what I'm talking about but it doesn't matter because neither does my fanbase" That's some serious ego shit right there that needs to be put in check. This is along the lines of idiot Kevin filming and riding in Whistler in a avy zone as they were blasting (this is why Kevin doesn't have an epic pass this year and isn't in Whistler).

I'm going to have to continue this...
“You've made this day a special day, by just your being you. There's no person in the whole world like you, and I like you just the way you are.”
 
ya'll think those khuno goggles are garbage? I was watching his crash vids and noticed that his lenses pop out of the goggles all of the time. is this a standard issue with magnetic lenses?
 
ya'll think those khuno goggles are garbage? I was watching his crash vids and noticed that his lenses pop out of the goggles all of the time. is this a standard issue with magnetic lenses?
I've never had Anon lenses pop out accidentally or during a crash. Mind you, I don't huck cliffs or forty-foot jumps either.
 
Gee not sure Avran..., JB looks like he's treated as a frigging park rat Superstar by all the teenage hommies at Powder Ridge Resort. Backflip Benton throwing it out there. JB promoting heaps of Merch' $$$$$$$$. I wonder if he got a free pass again??? "Don't forget..., smash that like button".

I've noticed a lot a these "Pro" vloggers never ever put the safety bar down on the chairlifts. In Australia it's always down on the lifts. So just wondering...., is this the latest "Cool" rule breaking norm coming out off the US of A we need to follow now???


 
ya'll think those khuno goggles are garbage? I was watching his crash vids and noticed that his lenses pop out of the goggles all of the time. is this a standard issue with magnetic lenses?
I got a buddy who bailed and yardsaled... his Anon magnetic lenses popped off and were lost.

The goggles are the first thing to go when bailing hard.

But... it shouldn't be happening all the time. That bail i mentioned above was pretty hard.

Sent from my Samsung using Tapatalk
 
*Continued...

So if you want to talk about the proliferation of his growth and what not lets dive into the shitty side of YouTube.

Everyone thinks it's as simple as film, upload, and promote and you're there. But behind all that is the grand YouTube algorithm that we are all beholden to. Buckhouse came onto YouTube at what is the start of the end of the Vlog lifestyle crap that has dominated it. We're actually in a shift from that to what will be next i.e. Mr. Beast style content for those that know. At that time YT was favoring content going to a longer format as they can add a mid roll video ad to it. This favors Google Ads as well as the content producer as it's keeping people on the app, site, or wherever its embedded. Most people think the real metric for success is subscribers and views, but a view is counted after 30 seconds of watching and most subscribers aren't addicts that watch everything, they're casual viewers. The real metric is view time and audience retention. If you do a 5 minute video you want them to watch over 3 minutes of it and if they stick around through the whole thing and watch what's recommended next then you get preferential treatment. If you make a 20 minute video and keep peoples attention for 50% of that it means it hits the mid roll ad and that preferential treatment comes back into play. So by gaming the system with a 20 minute video full of a shit load of filler and merchandise hawking he's hitting this goal. Now one other metric to look at is subscriber count to views in the first 24 hours. YouTube will naturally promote it to 1/3rd of your audience, if it hits the above listed goals you might be able to hit 50% of your audience and if it exceeds that you'll his 2/3rds of it which is insane. After that the algorithm changes again and shit gets weird. I won't bore you guys with the theories on how this works. But just understand if you're in a niche, using clickbait titles/thumbnails, and hit their metrics of time/audience retention you get boosted.

The daily content grind exists because of this format. If you don't do a daily video, you get buried in the algorithm. So he's beholden to clickbait bullshit and mediocre daily content to stay relevant. Andy Warhol was right about our 15 minutes of fame. The problem is we now have to prolong it to stay relevant. The sad thing is he doesn't realize this nor does he realize the peaks and valleys of how content is consumed. He's put all his eggs in one basket and when it doesn't work out he's FUBAR!

I guess I should also add the live streaming segment into this. YouTube is failing to Twitch here so they're trying to figure out what does and doesn't work. But this is mostly personality based. I've suffered through having to watch some of his and Kevins live streams to see how much audience they attract. They roughly get about .1% of their audience when they do it. Why? Near as I can tell the sycophant fanboys are there and the rest of their audiences find them boring as they don't give actual value, and why would they? This is them unedited in raw form, they aren't entertaining people. This also goes to why you will more than likely never see a Bombhole with Buckhouse, he can't control the narrative and it would show how boring he is.

In short for those that are still with me here. He makes kook content for kooks. He's not a snowboarder, but a person that snowboards and vlogs. Nothing wrong with that, but the fact that he takes from snowboarding with 0 giving back (don't use the argument of him making content is giving back, that's his job if he wants a paycheck he has to make content), at the end of the day he sucks as a human. If you don't like his content don't watch it, report the shit that is dangerous because there's plenty (I'm honestly waiting for him or Kevin to get someone killed with their kookery), and inform people not to watch him.

And for those of you that will say "you're just jealous". I took 10 weeks off last year, I snowboard 150 days a year, and get paid to ride a piece of wood and plastic down the hill. I think I'm doing just fine. What I don't like is fighting all the misinformation and bad advice he and Kevin give people. If they didn't do that, more power to them for figuring out how to snowboard more and make a living at it. Remember only you can prevent kookery in snowboarding.

Thank you for coming to my TED Talk.
Oh. I thought he had decided to roam and be free.

Too bad he got his pass taken; but this is not really surprising. A lot of people watch his content so there must be something interesting in it. But also... a lot of people are truly clueless, so you gotta be SUPER careful when giving "directions". If he was just riding and sending it... no problema. But as soon as he gives direction, it becomes more of an issue.

There's a Whistler ski dude... he and his crew SEND IT. But they don't give much direction or info that's not already "official".



Sent from my Samsung using Tapatalk
 
We have reeeeeaaaaal old double chairs here with the fold down safety bars that go across your lap. Nobody here really uses them, but I did have one hook my hood as I was getting off the lift and drag me around the corner...

Sent from my Pixel 5 using Tapatalk
 
61 - 80 of 354 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
You have insufficient privileges to reply here.